Aug 31 2008
Karate… kung fu… whatever.
Many people today in the Western World, think of all martial arts as one and the same thing. While it may be true, that a typical Western mindset includes lumping the unknown into a box with other, similar unknown things, it is not true that the various world martial arts are all the same thing. In reality, they may all have the same basic premise, to fight, but they are starkly different from one and other in contrast.
When many people think kung fu, they think JeanClaude VanDam, Steven Segal, Bruce Lee and Chuck Norris. The only person in that group with any Gong Fu was Bruce Lee, and he never finished his training. Every now and then, I have the wonderful oppurtunity to run into a pretentious American karate or tae kwon do black belt, which is usually as delightful as scraping my fingernails along a chalkboard while eating paste. When martial arts enter the conversation, and people that do pretend martial arts, often enjoy bringing it up, I first cringe, then confess… I’m really not interested.
It’s long been said, that all martial arts are equal. It is only a matter of who has learned them and what that individual has done with the information that they have aquired. I disagree. While I can respect anyone who works hard at anything, why waste your time collecting canine excrement for a tea party?
Tae Kwon Do was not originally designed for fighting, it was invented in Korea for the sake of international competition.
Here is the real root of Japanese Karate. When the Manchus were being trained to go to the north and fight the Mongol armies, they were taught basic empty hand Gong Fu. Low level punches, kicks and combinations. When they arrived at the border, some of them fled, and ended up on Japanese soil finding refuge with local people. They taught these local people their simple bare hand sequences which were retained, passed down and called “China Hand” or “Kara Te” which is one word “Karate”. What they didn’t get is any real teaching from a gong fu master or any of the many things that go along with training gong fu.
Sadly, this is true, and it is a harsh and embaressing truth for many long term exponents of Japanese Karate. It is often mentioned in various publications but usually put too politely like this; ” Japanese martial arts stem from Shaolin ” or ” Kung Fu is at the root of all asian martial arts” even ” Kung Fu is called ‘Mother Fist of Asia’ “. Let’s be blunt, and clear.
Just because someone “practices kung fu” doesn’t mean that what they are doing actually amounts to anything either. A person with a poor understanding of basic principles won’t get anywhere in kung fu, and “kung fu” takes on the same meaning as karate, and often has even less value. Karate, real, authentic Karate, is a formidable way of fighting. It included realistic weapons, real kung fu concepts inferred at a later point in history and some real kung fu training methods. Real Karate, is good basic Gong Fu. It’s also rarer than a three dollar foodstamp and sadly the same goes for real Kung Fu in America. Arrogance, and real skills, simply do not mesh. Arrogance, or more specificly false confidence, is a growing part of American culture.
If you can’t accept Chinese culture, you can’t accept kung fu. Whether your a Japanese Scholar or an American College Student.
The most basic idea, is that you start with a crude, rudimentary fighting concept. Lift your hand and smack the top of someones head, or reach out and grab a persons throat, lift your leg and step it down on a persons stomach, whatever. You then proceed to practice that crude fighting, over and over… and over… and over… and over… Eventually you can actually use it under stress. A good teacher will guide you, with the same information that they were guided in. Now you can move on to the next thing, built on this basic set of ideas, and new concepts might be introduced, all with the same basic idea… over… and over… and over. There is no other way.
There is an infinitude of possible paths to pursue in gong fu. More than one person could ever actually attain results in. Regardless of what your practicing, the key is practice. Real concentrated practice, not vacant redundant repetition. This is the real meaning of Gong Fu. “The fruit of diligently and consciously practiced diliberate actions”.